assessment criteria

The jury’s adjudication criteria
The submitted design concepts are evaluated according to the highest standards. The adjudication process follows a canon of strict criteria, which is constantly adapted to the latest findings in formal, technical, manufacturing, societal, industrial and ecological requirements. These criteria provide a guiding framework, which is filled in individually by each juror.  

Degree of innovation
Is the product concept new in itself or does it supplement an existing product with a new, desirable quality?

Aesthetic quality
Is the product concept’s form pleasant to look at?

Realisation possibility
Does current technology allow for the concept to be realised? If not with current technology, do you foresee the possibility of realisation in 1 to 3 years time?

Functionality and usefulness
Does the concept fulfil all requirements of handling, usability, safety, and maintenance? Does it fulfil a need or function?

Manufacturing efficiency / Cost of manufacturing
Can the concept be manufactured within a reasonable cost?

Ergonomics and human interface
Is the product concept adapted appropriately to the physical and, if necessary, psychic conditions of the user? 

Emotional content

What does the product concept offer the user beyond its immediate practical purpose in terms of sensual quality, possibilities of a playful use or emotional attachment?

Is your concept eligible for entry? Find out here.

Do you know what information is needed to enter the red dot award: design concept 2007? Click here.